Discussing http://www.masoncityillinois.org. I installed All in One SEO and it works fine. I installed Google web tools, and it says I'm all indexed. I put the words "Mason City Illinois" everywhere...titles, meta, site content.
Despite all this work, when I search "Mason City Illinois" on Google I don't show up anywhere in the first several pages. When I search for "masoncityillinois.org" it only shows my site after trying to get me to switch my search to ".com" instead.
It is a great city site, but no one can find it, and the city council is getting impatient. I am ready to make a real effort if I can get some help. Thank you.